20 comments

  • jtickle 1 day ago
    This seems exactly like the sort of shenanigan that would piss off rather than appease the wood spirits.
  • nkmnz 1 day ago
    What’s next? Touch-grass-as-a-Service?
  • weirdish 1 day ago
    I'd only buy this if it included a subscription-based AI upsell to predict and adapt to my adjusting superstition needs over time
  • yetihehe 1 day ago
    Knocking on wood was about knocking on unpainted wood, so that you have actual direct physical contact with wood. Remote knocking seems to go in the other direction...
    • thaumasiotes 1 day ago
      > Knocking on wood was about knocking on unpainted wood, so that you have actual direct physical contact with wood.

      How do you know this? For example, there is a wikipedia page section entitled "Origin of use in the English language"...

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knocking_on_wood#Origin_of_use...

      but the contents of that section make it extremely clear that no relevant facts are known to wikipedia.

      • yetihehe 22 hours ago
        I know it from Polish usage. In Polish it's "odpukać w niemalowane [drewno]"/"knocking on unpainted [wood]", wood is typically not spoken, the important part is that the wood is unpainted/raw. Superstitious people would especially leave the underside of table unpainted or leave some unpainted wood nearby in living room just for this occasion.
      • pessimizer 1 day ago
        The contents of the article make it clear that "touch wood" is basically synonymous with "knock on wood," making the knocking less important than the touching.

        But is is important to mention that a ctrl-f on that page for "unpainted" is proof that you didn't spend much time looking.

        • thaumasiotes 22 hours ago
          Do you have reason to believe that the article knows something about the origin of this practice that no one else in the world knows? The claim is set in the past, not the present. And it has to be, since there is no present significance to unpainted wood in English-speaking cultures.
      • couchand 1 day ago
        N >= 2
  • krunck 1 day ago
    There are societies where rather than knocking on wood one turns one's head and spits. For example: "Grandad is looking well after his fall, let's hope that doesn't happen again. Ptew!"

    Looking for this in app form.

    • random_cat_8745 1 day ago
      the true SaaS (Spit as a Service).
      • markdown 1 day ago
        I'm imagining a thousand people in a spitshop in (Mechanical) Turkey in a sitting at desks with a spittoon, waiting for a signal to spit.
  • skinfaxi 1 day ago
    Found this other experiment, part of the same series "Machines Responding to Superstitions".

    https://www.dezeen.com/2023/10/31/kinky-kashayam-portable-bl...

    Though it seems less like machine response than humans integrating technology into superstitious belief.

  • TehCorwiz 1 day ago
    If an app knocks on a tree and nobody is around…
  • psadri 1 day ago
    Whoever created this - you are the crazy kind of person I want to meet in real life.
  • gexla 1 day ago
    I wonder if I could create a full time job for myself tossing salt over my shoulder.
  • dvh 1 day ago
    It's like FakeBlock from Arrested development
  • gosen 1 day ago
    I can't explain why but it's amazing! Maybe because in my culture "knocking on the wood 3 times" helps to avoid the bad luck and I lived with that for 20 years, or maybe it's just fun to imagine that you're knocking on the wood remotely ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
  • itissid 1 day ago
    I am ratting this out to the Tree Beard
  • dr_pyser 1 day ago
    I never had to knock on wood
    • filoeleven 19 hours ago
      But I know someone who has. Which makes me wonder if I could, despite it being anecdata.
    • petters 23 hours ago
      Me neither knocks on wood
  • Cpoll 1 day ago
    Looking forward to one that will let me touch grass from my computer.
  • ButlerianJihad 1 day ago
    Nothing can surprise me. Every day at college, I would walk past these "Trees".

    https://stuartcollection.ucsd.edu/artist/allen.html#about-th...

  • hackersnooze1 17 hours ago
    superstition as a service?
  • lofaszvanitt 1 day ago
    You have to do it with a right hand, from under. So this is 100% fake.
  • classified 1 day ago
    The knockers are missing solar panels to continuously charge their batteries. So there will be sustained costs to keep them running. And how water-proof are they? Apart from that, it's going to sell like hot cakes.
  • tinyplanets 1 day ago
    Or just, you know, walk outside in the fresh air, find a nearby tree, and knock on it...
  • slipperybeluga 1 day ago
    [dead]